Skip to content

iCloud lock, carrier lock, MDM and blacklist: the four locks on a used phone

Published

"Locked" is the most confusing word in the used-phone market, because it can mean four completely different things. Each lock is stored in a different place, controlled by a different party and removed in a different way. A phone can have none of them, one, or all four at once.

Knowing which lock you are looking at tells you who can solve it, and whether the phone is worth buying.

1. iCloud Activation Lock (Find My)

Who controls it: the owner's Apple Account. When Find My is on, Apple ties the device to that account. After an erase, the device asks for the Apple Account email and password before it can be used.

How it shows: the setup screen says the device is locked to its owner and asks for the Apple Account. In a check report, Find My or FMI reads ON.

Who can remove it: the owner, by signing out on the device or removing it from their account. Apple can help an original owner with proof of purchase.

2. Carrier lock (SIM lock)

Who controls it: the carrier that sold the phone. For iPhones the lock is an activation policy stored by Apple and applied at every activation; Android phones store it on the device.

How it shows: SIM Not Supported, or no service with another carrier's SIM, while the original carrier's SIM works. In a check report the activation policy names the carrier and SIM-lock reads Locked.

Who can remove it: the carrier, once its conditions are met, usually the phone being paid off and a minimum time on the network.

3. MDM (remote management)

Who controls it: an organisation, such as a company, school or leasing firm. Devices bought through Apple Business Manager or Apple School Manager are registered to the organisation on Apple's servers.

How it shows: a Remote Management screen during setup asking for the organisation's credentials, or a management profile in Settings. In a check report MDM Lock reads ON.

Who can remove it: the organisation, by releasing the device from its MDM and from Apple Business Manager.

4. IMEI blacklist

Who controls it: carriers, through the shared GSMA database and their own systems. A phone reported lost or stolen, and in some cases one with an unpaid contract, is listed by IMEI.

How it shows: no service on networks that read the list, even with a valid SIM, while Wi-Fi and everything else work. In a check report the GSMA status reads BLACKLISTED.

Who can remove it: only the carrier that listed it.

How to tell them apart quickly

  • Asks for an Apple Account at setup: Activation Lock.
  • Asks for an organisation login at setup: MDM.
  • Sets up fine, but another carrier's SIM gets SIM Not Supported: carrier lock.
  • Sets up fine, but no SIM gets service on some networks: blacklist.

Why you should check all four

They are independent. An unlocked phone can be blacklisted; a clean IMEI can still have Find My on; a phone with Find My off can still be enrolled in MDM. A single report that covers Find My, iCloud status, MDM and carrier lock, plus a GSMA blacklist check, covers all four in two requests.

Check a device

Check all four locks by IMEI or serial number before you buy.

Read next